Stack Overflow Talent aims to connect the right company with the right developer. We call this a two-sided market – developers on one side and recruiters on the other.
One challenge is that the recruiter side of the market is not always technical. Many clients struggle to understand technology skill sets and ecosystems.
This is understandable! It’s a jungle of jargon (a jargle?) out there, and those of us on the inside don’t realize how inscrutable it all is.
This plays out in Stack Overflow’s candidate database, a product offered to recruiters to search for candidates of different skills. (Developers can opt in to this database with their developer story.)
The candidate database uses Elastic on the back end. Elastic is pretty good out of the box, but like other databases, it’s quite literal – to get a match, you have to search for precise terms that appear in developer stories.
We observed that recruiters’ search terms didn’t always meet this standard. For example, ‘front end’ is a common search, as are ‘mobile’ and ‘.Net’. Some developers use those terms in their developer stories, but more often, skills are expressed more granularly.
We know that an Angular expert is a front end person; we know that iOS implies mobile, and that C# is .Net – but databases such as Elastic do not.
The result is that recruiters miss good, appropriate candidates (which we heard quite a lot from Stack’s customer success team).
Query expansions, v1
Great advice. But shouldn’t the system already know this?
So we made the system know that. The first implementation (by me) was crude as could be, in order to test the theory as cheaply as possible.
We intercepted the raw query text and literally did a string replace:
We eyeballed the search results, got feedback from the customer success team, and put it into production. The results, while anecdotal, were positive.
In turn, we repeated this process for other common search terms: sysadmin, mobile, data science. We sprinkled in some regex to tolerate minor variations.
Query expansions, v2
We solved some obvious problems, but one can see the limits in the above approach. Substrings are a problem, as are n-grams.
The next step was to move this logic down into the query-parsing infrastructure. By doing so, we operate on a real syntax tree, with real tokens, and avoid “stringy” edge cases. We added a simple library for making substitutions, and eliminated regex.
There is a bit of a performance hit in the database with long
OR statements, on the order of 10% if I recall. We consider this acceptable for the improvement in user outcomes.
A further optimization might be to move expansions into Elastic itself, by writing an analyzer. Think of it as an ‘expansion in reverse’: when (say) ‘css’ is detected in a document, tag the document with the term ‘front end’, which can be indexed and searched efficiently.
As of this writing, Stack Overflow Talent offers query expansions for a few dozen common search terms (examples below). The result is that the customer success team needs to recommend ‘tips and tricks’ less often; demos by salespeople are more impressive; and most importantly, developers are more likely to be found by the right companies.
Thanks to Benjamin Hodgson for contributing to this essay.
Appendix: example query expansions
A non-exhaustive list, for illustration.
mobile → (ios or android or swift or objective-c or react-native or xcode or…)
full stack → (ruby on rails or asp.net or django or spring or mvc or flask or…)
sysadmin/devops → (sre or networking or dns or docker or cisco or iptables or…)
security → (encryption or infosec or owasp or harden or pki or kerberos or…)
embedded → (arm or rtos or microcontroller or qnx or wind river or asic or fpga or verilog or…)
kernel → (operating system or interrupt or scheduler or mutex or semaphore or userland or…)
cloud → (aws or ec2 or s3 or azure or gcp or kubernetes or…)
fintech → (quant or trading or banking or goldman or two sigma or bloomberg or jane street or…)
data science/ML/AI → (probability or predictive or r or ggplot or pandas or neural network or…)
distributed → (kafka or spark or hadoop or mapreduce or cockroachdb or concurrency or mvcc or…)