There has been some fun stuff today following Steve Jobs missive on Flash and standards. Joe Hewitt (former Facebook and Mozilla dev and rock star):
How it should go: browsers innovate differently, users pick the best one, later W3C standardizes what users chose, losing browsers conform.
Browsers aren’t innovating. They are just trying to comply with standards and fix bugs and performance
- Right now browser updates fix bugs and add application features, but can’t enhance the functionality of the web. This is only done by standards boards.
- Browsers are forced to implement every "standard" that is agreed on, even if it’s not the best decision for the platform.
- Browsers don’t add functionality outside of standards because developers wouldn’t utilize them. This means they can’t innovate.
- Browsers don’t even comply with standards well. Developing for the web is a disaster because every browser has its own quirks and issues. They can’t even do one thing right.
Which got me to thinking about the case of web browser standards: what good are they?
On a base level, a piece of software has to comply with some standards to be called a web browser. Can it render HTML, CSS and JS? OK, it’s probably a web browser.
But beyond that, the passion for standardization is about one particular use case: the ability to switch between different brands of software and achieving the same experience.
Think about that. If all browsers do the same thing, why would anyone switch? Do you know any normal (non-techie) person who cares about their web browser? And as browsers converge on standards, they will have even less reason to care.
Switching is a use case that applies to almost no one. And yet we obsess about it.
iPhone apps are not based on a community standard, and they often rock. People certainly like them.
Browser innovation is happening, and I am glad. I love Chrome. It competes on performance and usability. Firefox does the same, plus their add-on ecosystem.
And I understand the downside of inconsistent browsers. As a web dev, I benefit from standards. But does the consumer?
Consider what we are losing: serious innovation. It’s all happening elsewhere. Yes, browser standards do evolve as with HTML5. But as Hewitt alludes to, HTML5 is Flash 2003. If we had waited for HTML5, we’d have no web video.
Heck, I was able to do things with Filemaker in the early 90’s that I still couldn’t do on the Web in the mid-00’s. I traded “rich” for “reach”. Maybe rich is fighting back.
man, hack off a site you got here =) Last night I found another real good page where you can find bittorrent files for units like ds, wii, xbox, PC a.s.o. Will defi return here soon!
Without this blog I would have not know anything about it.
You can pre-order the iPhone 4G Unlock today so you’re ready to unlock your iPhone 4G as soon it’s released. Meaning you can use it out the box on any network of your choice!
I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
Intresting post, i really enjoyed reading it.
Thanks for this advisory article. I am constantly looking for knowledge on particular subjects and it’s rarely far away on the net. I’ll be coming back soon.
Intresting post, i really enjoyed reading it.
I definitely like this particular web page very much. This is extremely helpful and even extremely well done.Thanx a lot for this.Anyway I suggest you to check my site too if you wish.Summertime is on its way and we have the best fitflops online shop of the cyberspace.We are experts in fit flops and extremely experienced. Congratulations again for your blog.
Intresting post, i really enjoyed reading it.
I was supposed to be studying but I�m glad I surfed into this info and it was a match for what I was looking for, namely this subject. So why is it so hard to find good information on blogs these days?
Thanks for your very informative post, I have bookmarked your site, thanks much!
Finally the content of this blog is serious
Throughout the great pattern of things you’ll secure an A with regard to hard work. Where you actually lost me personally was on the specifics. You know, people say, details make or break the argument.. And it couldn’t be more accurate at this point. Having said that, let me inform you exactly what did give good results. Your writing can be quite engaging and this is probably the reason why I am making the effort to comment. I do not really make it a regular habit of doing that. Next, although I can see a jumps in logic you come up with, I am not confident of exactly how you appear to unite your details which inturn make your conclusion. For right now I shall yield to your position but wish in the future you actually connect the facts better.